Silent Spring – Book Review

Silent Spring Book CoverThis March, in honor of Women’s History Month, I read Silent Spring, by environmental pioneer, Rachel Carson. I selected the 40th-anniversary edition which includes an introduction by the biographer, Linda Lear and an afterword by author and scientist, Edward O. Wilson.

Simple, beautiful, and evocative illustrations by Lois and Louis Darling begin each chapter.

Book Review

In a way, Silent Spring is a classic tale of warfare—us against them. The war described in the book is between man and other members of nature, specifically unwanted insects (pests) and to a lesser extent unwanted plants (weeds). As with all wars, there is collateral damage and unintended consequences. The weapons of this war were pesticides, herbicides, and other toxic chemicals, many of which were byproducts of another war, World War II.

Readers learn about the impact of these “elixirs of death” on not only their intended targets of insect pests and weeds but also on the water, soil, plants, animals, and humans. Carson recounts the effects of widespread insecticide spraying operations that took place over millions and millions of acres of land, often repeatedly. In the end, the insects just came back in greater numbers as they adapted quickly to the poisons, but damage to plants, animals, and humans was long lasting and sometimes fatal.

The book tells of how chemical companies convinced farmers, ranchers, foresters, and governmental agencies that insecticides and herbicides were necessary and safe. They, in turn, informed the public there was nothing to worry about. The areas sprayed included forests, agricultural land, orchards, roadsides, and even residential neighborhoods. Many times insecticides and herbicides were applied without the consent of the public and often without any pre-notification.

Carson was not against killing insects that carry infection and disease, just the practice of killing off everything else at the same time. In the final chapter, she describes some alternatives. Silent Spring contains a lot of scientific information, research, facts, and examples. The 50 or so pages at the end of the text contain Carson’s sources.

One section in the book that struck me described an effort to expand cattle grazing land by using herbicides to kill off sagebrush. Justice William O. Douglas tells of attending a meeting where citizen protests were discussed. A woman had opposed the plan as it would kill all the wildflowers. Justice Douglas said,

“Yet, was not her right to search out a banded cup or tiger lily as inalienable as the right of stockmen to search out grass or of a lumberman to claim a tree?”

The Bottom Line

Rachel Carson was a marine biologist and enjoyed writing about nature. She spent most of her professional life with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and was already an accomplished nature writer by the time Silent Spring was published in 1962.

The publication of Silent Spring brought the widespread use and effects of pesticides and herbicides into the public view and provided inspiration for environmentalists across the country.

Silent Spring unleashed an avalanche of attacks on Carson and many people tried to discredit her. In the end, her voice was not silenced and although Silent Spring was written over 50 years ago, Rachel Carson and her message live on.

The next time you grab a can of insecticide to kill an ant trail in your kitchen or a can of herbicide to spray to kill the crabgrass on your lawn, put the can away, and go read Silent Spring.

Related Posts


Author: Linda Poppenheimer

Linda researches and writes about environmental topics to share information and to spark conversation. Her mission is to live more lightly on Earth and to persuade everyone else to do the same.

One thought on “Silent Spring – Book Review”

  1. I remember reading “Silent Spring” when it was first published. I was either too young, too naive, or did not want to believe way back in the 60’s. My appreciation for nature was limited as a child but fortunately as an adult I have been exposed to wilderness areas, forests, wild flowers, natural wonders, the beauty of our planet. My moment of truth began when I saw Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth”. This was a powerful message. Lucky for us that someone with worldwide recognition got serious about how very fragile our planet is. “Nova” on PBS recently had an outstanding program, “Earth from Space”, describing the inter relatedness of our planet (wind, rain, snow, oceans, plants, fish, animals, habitats, sun, etc.) Many of the amazing photos were taken by our myriad of satellites that are now circling our planet. There really is no excuse for not believing that we must all get serious and make a difference in any way we can. “Later” is a frightening word we can no longer use in any discourse about the future of our planet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.